Skip to content
Menu
SAG Watchdog
  • Home
  • Classics
  • Links
  • Contact
  • About
  • Archives
    • Archives

Close Menu
July 7, 2017

Labor Department Document Sheds New Light On Secret 2011 SAG Dues Hike; Union Responds – Update

Arlin Miller

by David Robb

July 7, 2017 4:14pm

UPDATED with SAG-AFTRA statement, 5:14 PM: A U.S. Department of Labor document obtained by SAG-AFTRA presidential candidate Peter Antico is raising new questions about the Screen Actors Guild’s decision to secretly raise the dues of 771 high-earning actors back in 2011. The secret dues hike, which reportedly raised $1.5 million for the union, targeted some of the biggest names in Hollywood including Tom Cruise, Angelina Jolie, Johnny Depp, Ray Liotta, Helen Hunt, Tea Leoni, James Cromwell, Julie Christie and Kevin Kline.

Related

DEAL! SAG-AFTRA & Producers Reach Tentative Agreement On New Film & TV Contract; Read The…

Antico, who says he’s running for president to bring more transparency to the union, obtained the DOL document – and many others – through the Freedom of Information Act. “The report is further evidence of the lack of honesty and transparency present at SAG-AFTRA,” he told Deadline. “It’s about time that SAG-AFTRA vote in honest leaders.”

In a statement to Deadline, SAG-AFTRA spokeswoman Pam Greenwalt said: “We have not been contacted by the Department of Labor and are surprised to see this conversation being revived again after thoroughly debunking the false suppositions several years ago,” . “Further, we have not seen nor been advised of the existence of the ‘purported’ document. Having dealt with these unfounded and incorrect accusations once, we have no further comment.”

SAG-AFTRA

When the Los Angeles Times first revealed the secret dues hike two years ago during the run-up to the union’s last election, SAG-AFTRA officials said that it had all been on the up and up. Then-union President Ken Howard told the Times that the hike was initiated by prominent SAG members who believed they were not paying enough dues. “This was brought to our attention by some of our high-profile members, and there was a lot of support for it,” he said. “It all seemed very positive to me.”

Howard died last year and was succeeded by Gabrielle Carteris, who is expected to seek another term. Elections will be held in August.

Membership dues are based on a percentage of earnings reported by production companies to the SAG Pension & Health Trust Funds. At the time, no dues were charged on earnings of more than $1 million, but today dues are capped after $500,000.

RelatedNo Voter Turnout In Three SAG-AFTRA Local Elections

“This led to under-billing in certain cases and, therefore, a built-in inequity in our dues structure,” SAG-AFTRA spokeswoman Pam Greenwalt told the Times. “In 2011, the union reviewed its methodology for assessing work dues and, after a discussion by and the unanimous approval of the finance committee, introduced a more accurate method.”

The newly discovered DOL document, however, raises serious questions about the veracity of the union leaders’ account of the secret dues hike. 

In 2012, the DOL was conducting two separate investigations of SAG and its Pension & Health Plans. One probe would uncover a $54,000 embezzlement of actors’ residuals by Michelle Dancy, the former manager of the union’s residuals estates and trust department, and the other found a $2.7 million kickback and embezzlement scheme by Nader Karimi, the of head information technology at the SAG Pension & Health Plans.

On the morning of June 12, 2012, just six weeks after the merger of SAG and AFTRA, a DOL special agent sat down for an interview with a female source – either a current or former SAG staffer – whose name and title are redacted from the agent’s report (read it here).

“In May of 2011,” the agent wrote after conducting the interview, “the union randomly increased the amount of reportable earnings for 771 members so that their reportable earnings reflected the maximum amount ($1 million) that they could be charged for dues. SAG records were created to reflect this higher amount even though their reportable earnings were lower based on the Trust reports.”

The source told the special agent that she became aware of the problem “when several members began to question the amount of dues they were being charged by the union. Seventy-one members had called complaining about how they were being charged.”

The source said that some of those who complained were asked to provide their IRS W-2 forms “so that their dues could be adjusted,” but the source alleged that “the practice of requesting the W-2’s was to further the fraud since the dues amount should have been based on reportable earnings to the Trust Fund and not actual earnings as reported on W-2’s.”

RelatedReport Exonerates SAG-AFTRA Execs Accused Of Misdeeds

The source provided the special agent with the names of many SAG staffers who she said were aware of the overcharging but said she “does not believe that SAG board members are aware of what was going on.” She added that “those involved did this because they wanted to hold on to their jobs.”

The members were overcharged “because the union was having financial problems,” she told the special agent, and “the overcharging of dues was an abuse of their responsibility to the membership.”

In his report, the special agent noted that “there were no additional payments to the pension and health fund as a result of the overcharging of membership dues,” meaning that dues were being paid on inflated earnings that weren’t producing any added income for the benefit plans.

No one at SAG-AFTRA ever was charged with wrongdoing because of the overcharging of dues.

Subscribe to Deadline Breaking News Alerts and keep your inbox happy

—

“The report is further evidence of the lack of honesty and transparency present at SAG-AFTRA,” he told Deadline. “It’s about time that SAG-AFTRA vote in honest leaders.”

Hmmm…Now there’s a refreshing thought!  You think!

 

Arl

The Ol’ SAG Watchdog

*Headline photo from the article

 

No Voter Turnout In Three SAG-AFTRA Local Elections DGA Pension Plan Moves To Bolster Retirement Funds.

Related Posts

2016, 2019

*SAG-AFTRA Podcast Addresses “Wigging” And “Paint Downs” In The Stunt Industry

2016, 2019

WME’s Ari Greenburg Says WGA “Not Interested In A Real Negotiation” In Packaging Dispute

2016, 2019

Writers Guild, Agencies Meet Again Without Obvious Progress

Recent Posts

  • Greedy Disney Keeps 80% of Streaming Revenue By Calling It ‘Home Video’
  • Trump Resigns From SAG-AFTRA
  • Trump Resigns from the Union
  • Budweiser Will Not Be Running a Commercial During the Super Bowl for the First Time in 37 Years
  • SAG-AFTRA National Board Orders Disciplinary Hearing for Donald Trump
  • LA Local SAG-AFTRA Members Release Grassroots Union Literacy Guide
  • Dave McNary, Beloved Longtime Variety Film Reporter, Dies at 69
  • Dave McNary Dies: Long-Time Variety Film Reporter Was 69
  • SAG-AFTRA Health Plan Class Action Lawsuit
  • Class-Action Lawsuit Says SAG-AFTRA Health Plan Cuts “Illegally Discriminate Based On Age”
  • SAG-AFTRA Health Plan Sued Over Benefit Cuts for Seniors
  • FilmLA Quickly Rescinded New Limits On After-Hours Filming In LA

Archives

Most Viewed Posts

  • Abra-Cadabra Now you see it! Now you don’t! Be the first on your block to take the SAG Watchdog Quiz to find out what disappeared from the SAG WebsiteAnd Why! (9350)
  • Ned Vaughn Resigns as SAG-AFTRA Exec VP to Run for Assembly! (5845)
  • Fi-Core Jon, George, Wilfred and More!!! (3661)
  • (MORE) Ineptness against Foot dragging: And the winner will be? (1582)
  • Pamela Greenwalt’s Warning to SAG-AFTRA Members (1541)
  • Links (1430)
  • (Article ADDED!!!) SAG-AFTRA Board Approves New Movie-TV Contract, Triggering Ratification Vote! (1365)
  • Ed Asner & Martin Sheen Advise a NO Vote (1257)
  • ‘Midnight Rider’ Accident: More Than 500 Gather for Candlelight Walk and Memorial For Sarah Jones! (1227)
  • WGA Members Ratify New 3-Year Deal! (1083)

Tags

2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2016 Gabrielle Carteris Headline Photo IATSE Jonathan Handel Ken Howard LA Los Angeles Membership First merger Midnight Rider National Board NBC Ned Vaughn New York NLRB NO Ol Dog Paul Edney PT Restore Respect Roberta Reardon RSVP SAG Scott Wilson Screen Actors Guild SVOD THR TV UFS UPDATE VP Watchdog WGA WGAW Writers Guild
Back To Top
SAG Watchdog
Web Design and Maintenance by ImagOvation